0
Broadcast & Satellite

Tivo loses patent office ruling

Wednesday 9 June 2010 | 10:00 CET | News
Tivo has lost a ruling from the US Patent and Trademark Office over validity of patents for its time-shift TV technology. The ruling comes after a second re-examination of the patents by the PTO, following challenges from pay-TV providers Dish and Echostar. A separate review of the patent infringement case brought by the companies is still pending. This has leaned heavily in TiVo's favor and could still lead to the satellite companies paying damages to the set-top box maker. But the PTO ruling could have ramifications for TiVo's case against AT&T and Verizon Communications over their DVR services. A jury in 2006 found Dish and EchoStar liable for infringing TiVo's DVR patent when they began making their own set-top boxes. The companies are going through a process called an en banc review to establish the legal ramifications of the decision, but most analysts believe TiVo will eventually emerge victorious, the Wall Street Journal writes. A federal judge imposed contempt sanctions last year after finding that a technological redesign developed by EchoStar and Dish still infringed TiVo's patent. The companies had argued their alternative removed all the DVR features that TiVo had accused of infringement. The en banc review will determine if the injunction and finding of contempt by both the district court judge and appeals court were appropriate. A federal appeals court in March handed a key legal victory to TiVo, temporarily clearing the way for it to collect about USD 300 million from the two companies. But the panel last month said it would rehear the matter. Dish and EchoStar said in a statement Tuesday that the claims rejected by the patent office are the same as those pending before the appeals court. TiVo called the patent-office move "separate and apart" from the appeals court matter.

Free Headlines in your E-mail

Every day we send out a free e-mail with the most important headlines of the last 24 hours. Subscribe now.

Categories: Broadcast & Satellite
Companies: AT&T / EchoStar / TiVo / Verizon
Countries: United States
::: add a comment

Add comment

We welcome comments that add value to the discussion. We attempt to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam, and our editors frequently review the comments to ensure they are appropriate. If you see a comment that you believe is inappropriate to the discussion, you can bring it to our attention by using the report abuse links. As the comments are written and submitted by visitors of the Telecompaper website, they in no way represent the opinion of Telecompaper.






-0.5%
Fixed telephony market expected to decrease by 0.5% in 2015
Netherlands  |  2015

Calendar   /   Industry Events

20 Apr Rogers Communications Q1 2015
20 Apr Mobile Commerce and Banking Conference
20 Apr Telecoms Energy Efficiency Forum
20 Apr Open Mobile Media
20 Apr Monetising Big Data in Telecoms World Summit
20 Apr Fortinet Q1 2015
21 Apr Infinera Q1 2015
21 Apr Zhone Technologies Q1 2015
21 Apr Yahoo! Q1 2015
21 Apr TeliaSonera Q1 2015
21 Apr Tele2 Q1 2015
21 Apr ARM Holdings Q1 2015
21 Apr Broadcom Q1 2015
21 Apr Sky fiscal Q3
21 Apr Turk Telekom Q1 2015
21 Apr VMware Q1 2015
21 Apr Big Data and Predictive Analytics for Telecoms
21 Apr UC EXPO
21 Apr MVNOs World Congress
22 Apr Facebook Q1 2015
22 Apr Polycom Q1 2015
22 Apr Texas Instruments Q1 2015
22 Apr TE Connectivity fiscal Q2
22 Apr Logitech fiscal Q4
22 Apr MTG Q1 2015
22 Apr Crown Castle Q1 2015
22 Apr Millicom Q1 2015
22 Apr Adtran Q1 2015
22 Apr Telekom Austria Q1 2015
22 Apr AT&T Q1 2015
::: More Calendar Items