Nokia loses court ruling in Indian tax dispute

News Wireless India 12 FEB 2014
Nokia loses court ruling in Indian tax dispute
Nokia faces a setback in plans to transfer its Indian handset assets to Microsoft, after a new court ruling set additional conditions on the deal. In December, Nokia appeared to win an important reprieve in the group's USD 1.1 billion tax dispute in India, when a court in New Delhi ruled that company could transfer the Chennai factory. However, last week another court ruling imposed extra conditions on the company, which it said were "unacceptable", the Financial Times reports. 

Nokia said it would not be able to transfer the assets, and the ruling puts the continuity of its operations in India in jeopardy. It has filed an appeal with the Supreme Court in the hope of reversing the ruling. The court asked Nokia to make an open-ended guarantee that the company would meet any future tax claims relating to the dispute. Nokia said this would stop the group defending itself against claims, a step it is unwilling to take. Nokia’s original dispute related to tax allegedly due on payments by the group's Indian subsidiary to its Finnish parent.


 

Categories:

Mobile

Companies:

Nokia,  Microsoft

Countries:

India

Tags:

Legislation - Lawsuits, M&A buyouts & divestments

Related Articles

INDIA 27 NOV 2014

Lava to acquire Nokia's Chennai mobile phone plant – report

Indian smartphone vendor Lava International is in talks to acquire Nokia's Chennai handset factory. Lava and Nokia have signed a nondisclosure agreement, people familiar with the talks told The Economic Times. "Lava's manufacturing team has already visited the plant and has done the assessment. It will make a proposal to Nokia mid-December after taking all aspects into consideration," one of the people said.

INDIA 15 MEI 2014

Nokia seeks arbitration in Indian tax dispute

India is seeking international arbitration with India's government over the tax dispute that prevented the transfer of its main Indian factory to Microsoft last month. An asset freeze ordered by tax officials prevented Nokia in late April from transferring its manufacturing facility in Chennai as part of the sale of its phone business sale to Microsoft. Nokia said that it had written to Manmohan Singh, India's prime minister, citing the bilateral investment treaty between India and Finland, marking the firs

INDIA 16 APR 2014

Nokia offers voluntary retirement to Chennai plant workers

Nokia India has said that its voluntary retirement scheme for employees of its Chennai plant is entirely optional. The plant employs around 8,000 workers but has been scaling down operations. Employees at the plant claimed Nokia is forcing them to accept the voluntary retirement scheme. Recently, the Supreme Court rejected Nokia's appeal and did not allow the company to transfer its assets to Microsoft as part of the two companies' USD 7.2 billion deal. Nokia is in a tax dispute which has stopped its plan t

INDIA 28 MRT 2014

Nokia plant employees stage hunger strike

Employees at Nokia's handset plant in Chennai will go on a one-day hunger strike on 31 March. The employees are concerned about the transfer of the plant to Microsoft under the two companies' USD 7.2 billion deal. The employees call on the state and central governments to ensure there will be no job losses, PTI writes. The plant was earlier operating at three shifts, producing 13 million handsets per month, but since January this has been cut to two shifts and production has dropped to 4 million handsets. "

INDIA 17 MRT 2014

Supreme Court rejects Nokia's appeal

India's Supreme Court has rejected Nokia's appeal against a Delhi High Court order which directed the company to give a guarantee covering its tax liabilities, in addition to the INR 22.50 billion that needs to be deposited in an escrow account before the company is allowed to transfer its handset factory in Chennai to Microsoft. Nokia has said it will now consider its next steps, the Economic Times reports. India's income tax department claims the deal between Microsoft and Nokia is aimed at stopping the g

INDIA 14 MRT 2014

Court seeks valuation of Nokia India assets in tax case

India's Supreme Court is seeking a valuation of the assets of Nokia India before examining the dispute between Nokia and the country's tax department. The income tax department claims that Microsoft's plans to buy Nokia India's assets without acquiring its liabilities will adversely affect its tax claims over the company and its parent company. The tax department says this could run into INR 212.51 billion. Although Nokia told the court the value of the assets are around INR 22 to 33 billion, the court want

INDIA 4 MRT 2014

Nokia told to solve India tax dispute

The Indian Supreme Court today asked Nokia India to bring out a concrete proposal to settle its tax dispute with the income tax department, The Economic Times reported. The court noted that the assets transfer to Microsoft would be taking place in two or three weeks. The court also said that its proposal to give a minimum deposit of INR 22.5 billion towards its tax liabilities was final. Nokia's counsel said over 35,000 jobs were created by the company in India and that the court would take the interests of

GLOBAL 17 FEB 2014

Nokia says India tax case to not affect Microsoft deal close

Nokia said it's recent setback in a tax case in India would not affect the planned closing of the sale of of its mobile phone business to Nokia. The transaction is still expected to close in the first quarter, subject to regulatory approvals and other customary closing conditions, irrespective of the proceedings in the Indian tax case, the company said in a statement. Earlier reports suggested that Nokia would not be able to close the deal, due to the outstanding tax claims against its India operations. 

INDIA 27 JAN 2014

Court rejects order for Nokia to put INR 35 bln in escrow

The Delhi High court has rejected the request of India's income tax department to order Nokia to deposit INR 35 billion into an escrow account for future tax demands. The court asked Nokia India for a "simple" undertaking that it has gone through the order and accepts the conditions, the Economic Times reports. In December, the High Court paved the way for the sale of Nokia's phone business to Microsoft by unfreezing assets in India. The conditions included that Nokia India would deposit a INR 22.5 billion

INDIA 12 DEC 2013

Nokia wins reprieve in India tax battle

Nokia has won a crucial reprieve in its tax battle with India's government, with a court in New Delhi ruling that the group can transfer its assets in the country as part of its EUR 5.4 bln phone business sale to Microsoft, reports The Financial Times. However, the court also ruled that the group must deposit INR 22.5 bln as a security against the eventual resolution of the tax dispute, which will continue once the asset transfer is completed.

INDIA 10 DEC 2013

Nokia offers India EUR 355 mln to transfer factory - report

Nokia is ready to pay at least EUR 355 million to India's tax authorities to enable the transfer of a factory in the country to Microsoft, two people familiar with the matter told Bloomberg. Nokia is willing to deposit at least EUR 270 million on top of an already announced amount of EUR 85 million if India's government allows the shifting of assets including the manufacturing plant in Chennai, said the people. The assets were frozen in September because of a tax dispute. Earlier that month, Nokia agreed to

INDIA 3 DEC 2013

Indian tax dept rejects Nokia's offer to pay INR 22.5 bln

India's Income Tax (IT) Department has told the Delhi High Court that the offer by Nokia to pay a minimum deposit of INR 22.5 billion to it, out of the company's total tax liability of nearly INR 65 billion, is not acceptable, reports PTI. Nokia India has stuck to its offer, however, and said it is for the department to decide if they are better off with the proposed amount or without it.

INDIA 22 NOV 2013

Nokia asks Indian court to help release factory

Nokia wants to resolve its tax dispute with the Indian government ahead of the sale of its mobile operations to Microsoft, Reuters reported citing sources. The company wants the government to release its factory in Chennai and has gone to the Delhi High Court for help. In a statement, Nokia said it wanted the assets to be released by 12 December. The court will hold a hearing on 28 November. Nokia said it did not expect the dispute to affect its EUR 5.4 billion deal with Microsoft, although it was prepared

INDIA 1 OKT 2013

Indian tax officials freeze Nokia assets

The Indian Income Tax Department has frozen some of Nokia's immovable assets including buildings and facilities in India, reports The Wall Street Journal. The department sought to ensure that the company has sufficient funds to pay an estimated INR 39.97 billion tax bill. After the initial seizure by the tax authorities, the company asked the Delhi High Court for an order to free up its Indian bank accounts. Nokia spokesman Brett Young declined to elaborate on the matter, but he said the company is still in

Just In

29 MEI 15:18

Netia offers 6 children's TV channels in open window in June

29 MEI 15:15

United Group agrees to sell Adria News Network to Alpac Capital

29 MEI 15:02

T-Mobile Poland runs short-term top-up bonus offer

29 MEI 15:00

Tet educates children in cybersecurity

Commentary

5 MEI 10:55

KPN: the art of making one-offs structural

4 MEI 14:25

Open Dutch Fiber outlook: time to restart roll-out?

20 APR 10:36

Netflix back to organic growth and doing just fine

11 FEB 12:29

Odido shareholders face tricky exit after abandoned IPO

Background

23 MEI 23:42

The week in telecom: Starlink ready to go public, Singapore telco M&A and Google courts AI subscribers at I/O

18 MEI 00:31

The week in telecom: US operators mount rural satellite challenge, Cisco cashes in on AI boom

11 MEI 00:53

The week in telecom: Lumen, NTT turn to data centre market to revive growth, Hutchison exits UK

3 MEI 23:05

The week in telecoms: big tech faces costs of AI boom and Wi-Fi market consolidates

Complete profile

Before downloading the whitepaper, we would like to ask you to complete your profile with company and position. After confirming you will receive the white paper.